.webp)
The ‘IR35’ term stands for the Inland Revenue (now HMRC) press release number 35 in which these rules were issued. In simple terms, what IR35 does is state that if a contractor works in the same way an employer does, the contractor ought to pay similar taxes and National Insurance as an employer.
IR 35, commonly referred to as the Intermediaries Legislation is a set of rules governing the United Kingdom taxation system aimed at preventing particular workers from supplying their services to the end client through an intermediary entity known as a personal service company if this worker would have been its employee if the intermediary entity did not exist. It is therefore important for business owners to understand what IR35 all is about if they are to avoid falling foul of it. This IR35 guide is for companies, businesses and everyone who operates in the UK.
IR35 meaning
IR35 is tax legislation designed to counter people who perform services to a client for someone else but if the middleman – often a limited company – was not in place, that person would be categorised as an employee. The idea here is to check that such people are paying the correct income tax and National Insurance.
Business implication of IR35
For businesses, IR35 entails that they must decide the employment status of contractors to ascertain to which side of the IR35 they belong. If a contractor is considered to fall within IR35 then your business will have to pay the taxes and National Insurance.
Understanding inside and outside IR: Explaining the IR35 terminology
Inside IR35 meaning
If a contractor is said to be inside IR35 then it implies that for taxation purposes the contractor is an employee. This classification also means that the business is obliged to take income tax and National Insurance from contractor’s fees and oversee making the payments to HMR&C.
Outside IR35 meaning
On the other hand, if a contractor is ‘outside IR35’ they are seen as being a genuine independent contractor who has to arrange their affairs with regard to taxation. This status can often be more financially advantageous for both the contractor and the business, as it reduces the administrative burden and associated costs.
The importance of IR35 compliance
IR35 compliance and its impact
The implementation of IR35 delivers important parameters toward achieving severe fines. HMRC can claim for backdated taxes and penalties and in some cases, even legal actions can also be taken against those businesses that have not complied with the provisions of the IR35 legislation. This can result in huge losses and image problems for individuals and the organisations they represent.
IR35 business compliance tips
1. Regular assessments: Carry out Ad-hoc IR35 checks of all contracts and trading relations at least once a year. This assists in keeping your business legal as situations change from one time to another.
2. Professional advice: Advising help from tax experts or legal advisors exclusively in IR35 is always advisable to overcome legal constraints easily.
3. Use of CEST tool: Check Employment Status for Tax (CEST) which is provided by HMRC is somewhat helpful in getting an idea of whether a contractor is inside or outside of IR35. Yet, this tool has been criticised, therefore, it should be used carefully and also one might need some extra consultation.
How to conduct an IR35 assessment
Factors influencing IR35 status
The following has been identified as key in deciding whether a contractor will be inside or outside IR35:
1. Control: If your business controls where, when, and how the contractor does their work, this points toward an employment contract and is therefore inside IR35.
2. Substitution: The possibility to cooperate with a substitute when sending a contractor is also evidence of conducting business activity and supports the outside IR35 classification.
3. Mutuality of obligation (MOO): E.g., where there is a duty imposed on the business to offer work and on the contractor to receive the assignment this may point towards an employment relationship.
4. Financial risk: Where the contractor assumes a level of financial risk or where the contractor is responsible for materials, or tools, or has had to pay for defects in his work he is likely to be considered an ‘outside’ IR35 contractor.
Do you wish to offshore and maximise your profit? If yes, read our guide on What is offshoring and Offshoring vs outsourcing, now! To start your remote team today- Connect with Jon.
Use our employee cost calculator to see the drastic savings you can make when you outsource.
IR35 Contract considerations
Contracts should be carefully drafted to reflect the true nature of the relationship between the business and the contractor.
1. Clear Terms and Conditions: Ensure that contracts explicitly state the contractor’s independence, lack of control by the business, and the absence of any mutual obligations to provide or accept work.
2. Consistency Between Contract and Practice: The actual working practices must match the terms outlined in the contract. HMRC will look beyond the contract to assess the reality of the working relationship.
The financial implications of IR35
IR35 tax implications
IR35 has significant tax implications for both contractors and businesses.
1. Income tax and national insurance: Contractors inside IR35 will have income tax and national insurance contributions deducted at source, similar to an employee. Businesses might also have to pay the employer’s national insurance.
2. Reduced expense claims: Contractors inside IR35 are limited in the expenses they can claim. Only expenses directly related to their employment, such as travel and subsistence, are deductible.
Managing IR35 expenses
Understanding how IR35 affects expenses is crucial for both contractors and businesses.
1. Deductible expenses for contractors: Contractors working inside IR35 can only claim expenses like travel, accommodation, and meals if they are necessary for the performance of their duties and not reimbursed by the client.
2. Business expense considerations: Businesses may need to adjust their budgets to account for the additional costs associated with hiring contractors who fall inside IR35, such as employer’s national insurance and potentially higher contractor rates to compensate for their reduced take-home pay.
IR35 and business strategy
Developing an IR35 business strategy
An effective IR35 strategy is vital for managing risks and maintaining a flexible workforce.
1. Reviewing contractor engagements: Regularly review all contractor engagements to ensure they are classified correctly under IR35. This might involve conducting audits or seeking external advice.
2. Financial planning: Factor in the potential costs associated with inside IR35 determinations, such as additional taxes and national insurance contributions, when planning budgets and setting contractor rates.
Managing IR35 risk
Mitigating risk involves staying informed and proactive in your approach to IR35.
1. Regularly update contracts: Keep contracts up to date with current IR35 legislation and ensure they reflect the actual working relationship.
2. Stay informed on IR35 news: IR35 rules are subject to change, so staying informed about the latest developments is essential for maintaining compliance and managing risk effectively.
3. Consider insurance options: Some businesses choose to take out insurance to cover potential liabilities arising from IR35 disputes. This can provide a safety net against unexpected tax demands and penalties.
Hire an HR to manage and ensure your business is well-compliant with the latest laws and regulations. Do you know even HR services can be offshored, read our blog “What is HR outsourcing services” for a better perspective.
The role of IR35 in business contracts
IR35 and business contracts
The structuring of contracts is a key factor in IR35 determinations.
1. Defining scope and autonomy: Contracts should clearly define the scope of work, the autonomy of the contractor, and any financial risks they are taking. This helps to support an outside IR35 classification.
2. Avoiding ambiguities: Any ambiguities in the contract could lead HMRC to challenge the IR35 status. Ensure that the language used in contracts is clear and unambiguous, particularly concerning the contractor's independence.
Ensuring contracts align with IR35 regulations
Aligning your contracts with IR35 regulations is crucial for avoiding misclassification.
1. Legal review of contracts: Have contracts reviewed by legal professionals with expertise in IR35 to ensure they comply with the latest legislation and accurately reflect the working relationship.
2. Consistency in practice: Ensure that the day-to-day working practices align with the terms set out in the contract. HMRC will scrutinise the actual working conditions to determine IR35 status, so consistency is key.
IR35 compliance for business owners
Key compliance steps for business owners
Business owners must take a proactive approach to ensure IR35 compliance across all contractor engagements.
1. Conduct regular IR35 audits: Regular audits of your contractor engagements will help identify any areas of non-compliance and allow you to take corrective action before HMRC intervenes.
2. Document decisions and processes: Keep detailed records of all IR35 assessments, including the rationale behind each decision. This documentation can be crucial in the event of an HMRC investigation.
IR35 compliance checklist
A checklist can help ensure that you cover all bases when it comes to IR35 compliance:
1. Assess all contractor roles regularly: Regular assessments will ensure that roles are correctly classified under IR35.
2. Use the CEST tool judiciously: While HMRC's CEST tool can be useful, it should be used as part of a broader assessment strategy, possibly supplemented by professional advice.
3. Maintain consistent contract terms and practices: Ensure that the terms of the contract and the actual working practices are aligned and consistent with an outside IR35 determination where applicable.
4. Review and update contracts regularly: As legislation and your business needs evolve, so should your contracts. Regular reviews are essential for maintaining compliance.
5. Consider IR35 insurance: Consider taking out insurance to cover potential liabilities related to IR35, particularly if your business frequently engages contractors.
IR35 legislation: A summary
Evolution of IR35 legislation
IR35 legislation has gone through a number of changes since it was first introduced in 2000 with the more recent and most comprehensive changes taking effect in april 2021 that transfers the responsibility of deciding on the operation of IR35 from contractors to the medium and large business entities that engage the contractors.
1. Public sector reforms: In the year 2017 the public sector contracts went through some changes that shifted the responsibility of deciding the IR35 status of contractors to the public bodies. Special measures related to these changes were introduced in the private sector for mid and large companies in 2021.
2. Current IR35 rules: If under the existing system, you come under the medium or large category, then it is your job to decide whether those who work for you as contractors fall under IR35. However, small business owners do not follow this requirement.
Staying updated with IR35 news
It is important to always keep abreast with any changes that are being made to IR35 to avoid falling foul of the law.
1. Legislative changes: IR35 rules are not water-tight and often there are changes to them, so it is important for a business to keep abreast of these changes in order to protect itself.
2. HMRC guidelines: The guidelines concerning the utilisation of IR35 change frequently. This means that it is essential to frequently update your IR35 reviews.
The final word on IR35 UK overview
IR35 for business owners is a complicated and ever-changing law that presents various challenges to businesses in the United Kingdom that hire contractors. It is important therefore that businesses understand what IR35 means and how to correctly classify contractors and have their contracts and business model fully compliant to the new changes.
Final thoughts are IR35 can be managed by identifying and preparing risks, making periodic evaluations, and springing to legislatively enacted changes. Having done this, there are certain risks involved which, if managed smartly, should not hinder one from enjoying the performance flexibility that contractors provide business organisations.
